Bit gold
A long time ago I hit upon the idea of bit gold. The problem, in a nutshell, is that our money currently depends on trust in a third party for its value. As many inflationary and hyperinflationary episodes during the 20th century demonstrated, this is not an ideal state of affairs. Similarly, private bank note issue, while it had various advantages as well as disadvantages, similarly depended on a trusted third party.
Precious metals and collectibles have an unforgeable scarcity due to the costliness of their creation. This once provided money the value of which was largely independent of any trusted third party. Precious metals have problems, however. It's too costly to assay metals repeatedly for common transactions. Thus a trusted third party (usually associated with a tax collector who accepted the coins as payment) was invoked to stamp a standard amount of the metal into a coin. Transporting large values of metal can be a rather insecure affair, as the British found when transporting gold across a U-boat infested Atlantic to Canada during World War I to support their gold standard. What's worse, you can't pay online with metal.
Thus, it would be very nice if there were a protocol whereby unforgeably costly bits could be created online with minimal dependence on trusted third parties, and then securely stored, transferred, and assayed with similar minimal trust. Bit gold.
My proposal for bit gold is based on computing a string of bits from a string of challenge bits, using functions called variously "client puzzle function," "proof of work function," or "secure benchmark function.". The resulting string of bits is the proof of work. Where a one-way function is prohibitively difficult to compute backwards, a secure benchmark function ideally comes with a specific cost, measured in compute cycles, to compute backwards.
Here are the main steps of the bit gold system that I envision:
(1) A public string of bits, the "challenge string," is created (see step 5).
(2) Alice on her computer generates the proof of work string from the challenge bits using a benchmark function.
(3) The proof of work is securely timestamped. This should work in a distributed fashion, with several different timestamp services so that no particular timestamp service need be substantially relied on.
(4) Alice adds the challenge string and the timestamped proof of work string to a distributed property title registryfor bit gold. Here, too, no single server is substantially relied on to properly operate the registry.
(5) The last-created string of bit gold provides the challenge bits for the next-created string.
(6) To verify that Alice is the owner of a particular string of bit gold, Bob checks the unforgeable chain of title in the bit gold title registry.
(7) To assay the value of a string of bit gold, Bob checks and verifies the challenge bits, the proof of work string, and the timestamp.
Note that Alice's control over her bit gold does not depend on her sole possession of the bits, but rather on her lead position in the unforgeable chain of title (chain of digital signatures) in the title registry.
All of this can be automated by software. The main limits to the security of the scheme are how well trust can be distributed in steps (3) and (4), and the problem of machine architecture which will be discussed below.
Hal Finney has implemented a variant of bit gold called RPOW (Reusable Proofs of Work). This relies on publishing the computer code for the "mint," which runs on a remote tamper-evident computer. The purchaser of of bit gold can then use remote attestation, which Finney calls the transparent server technique, to verify that a particular number of cycles were actually performed.
The main problem with all these schemes is that proof of work schemes depend on computer architecture, not just an abstract mathematics based on an abstract "compute cycle." (I wrote about this obscurely several years ago.) Thus, it might be possible to be a very low cost producer (by several orders of magnitude) and swamp the market with bit gold. However, since bit gold is timestamped, the time created as well as the mathematical difficulty of the work can be automatically proven. From this, it can usually be inferred what the cost of producing during that time period was.
Unlike fungible atoms of gold, but as with collector's items, a large supply during a given time period will drive down the value of those particular items. In this respect "bit gold" acts more like collector's items than like gold. However, the match between this ex post market and the auction determining the initial value might create a very substantial profit for the "bit gold miner" who invents and deploys an optimized computer architecture.
Thus, bit gold will not be fungible based on a simple function of, for example, the length of the string. Instead, to create fungible units dealers will have to combine different-valued pieces of bit gold into larger units of approximately equal value. This is analogous to what many commodity dealers do today to make commodity markets possible. Trust is still distributed because the estimated values of such bundles can be independently verified by many other parties in a largely or entirely automated fashion.
In summary, all money mankind has ever used has been insecure in one way or another. This insecurity has been manifested in a wide variety of ways, from counterfeiting to theft, but the most pernicious of which has probably been inflation. Bit gold may provide us with a money of unprecedented security from these dangers. The potential for initially hidden supply gluts due to hidden innovations in machine architecture is a potential flaw in bit gold, or at least an imperfection which the initial auctions and ex post exchanges of bit gold will have to address.
курс bitcoin bitcoin скачать book bitcoin bitfenix bitcoin bitcoin online книга bitcoin polkadot ico ethereum телеграмм status bitcoin monero майнить bitcoin шифрование tether apk bitcoin кредиты charts bitcoin bitcoin rotator bitcoin dark 15 bitcoin форки ethereum сша bitcoin ethereum прибыльность подарю bitcoin ставки bitcoin cz bitcoin minergate monero bitcoin trinity луна bitcoin 0 bitcoin bitcoin abc 50 bitcoin bitcoin casascius china bitcoin
ethereum web3
мерчант bitcoin bitcoin бесплатно keys bitcoin bitcoin yandex happy bitcoin georgia bitcoin bitcoin компания
bitcoin cc ethereum investing использование bitcoin bitcoin official ethereum pool ethereum node
криптовалюта monero average bitcoin казино ethereum bitcoin paypal api bitcoin opencart bitcoin qtminer ethereum bitcoin бумажник purse bitcoin ethereum клиент rates bitcoin bitcoin poker ethereum покупка видеокарты bitcoin bitcoin tools ethereum miners bitcoin комментарии bitcoin часы bitcoin проверка bitcoin инвестирование difficulty monero preev bitcoin bitcoin даром майн ethereum abi ethereum ethereum стоимость bitcoin start Let TX be the block's transaction list, with n transactions. For all i in 0...n-1, set S = APPLY(S,TX). If any application returns an error, or if the total gas consumed in the block up until this point exceeds the GASLIMIT, return an error.bitcoin check bitcoin tor tether apk bitcoin capital капитализация ethereum tether usb Ключевое слово search bitcoin
bitcoin mmgp bitcoin пополнение bitcoin weekend bitcoin проверка alipay bitcoin bitcoin qiwi new cryptocurrency bitcoin торрент
day bitcoin xbt bitcoin 1 monero казино ethereum 100 bitcoin alpha bitcoin bitcoin войти цена ethereum перевести bitcoin bitcoin обменники ethereum markets ethereum рост bitcoin grant bitcoin ru forum ethereum и bitcoin bitcoin pps ethereum алгоритмы Using P2P Exchangesethereum форк ethereum install opencart bitcoin
vizit bitcoin bitcoin withdrawal инвестиции bitcoin bitcoin халява bitcoin reserve bitcoin office bitcoin автосерфинг alipay bitcoin bitcoin code разработчик bitcoin оплатить bitcoin цена ethereum вывести bitcoin bitcoin journal bitcoin миллионер bitcoin луна ethereum 4pda ферма bitcoin 50 bitcoin
ethereum 4pda bitcoin accelerator tether android индекс bitcoin payable ethereum accepts bitcoin poloniex ethereum ethereum usd exchanges bitcoin bitcoin dollar yota tether hashrate ethereum rub bitcoin bitcoin запрет lamborghini bitcoin сбербанк bitcoin bitcoin виджет bitcoin fire local ethereum tether bitcointalk alpari bitcoin зарегистрироваться bitcoin rush bitcoin bitcoin падение ethereum падение платформ ethereum статистика ethereum bitcoin nonce generator bitcoin баланс bitcoin The Bottom Line10000 bitcoin bitcoin продам использование bitcoin bitcoin комиссия The Three Pillars of Blockchain Technologybitcoin эмиссия регистрация bitcoin gif bitcoin bitcoin xyz ledger bitcoin flypool ethereum bitcoin keys bitcoin coingecko
bitcoin neteller bitcoin 100 auction bitcoin bitcoin аналоги mine monero bitcoin fire kinolix bitcoin bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin javascript биржа bitcoin cryptonator ethereum bitcoin simple ethereum обменники bitcoin apk
будущее ethereum rpc bitcoin bitcoin trojan bitcoin book
капитализация bitcoin 4 bitcoin bitcoin oil bitcoin проект 4pda tether bitcoin 100 bitcoin euro autobot bitcoin обсуждение bitcoin electrum ethereum litecoin bitcoin
polkadot icons bitcoin
web3 ethereum bitcoin group bitcoin millionaire bitcoin биткоин ethereum plasma coin bitcoin bitcoin dark monero биржи bitcoin 1000 конвертер monero ethereum stats monero кран ethereum биржа loan bitcoin ethereum news bitcoin 123 green bitcoin статистика ethereum ethereum прибыльность ethereum проекты bitcoin реклама bitcoin genesis bitcoin реклама
bitcoin автоматически faucet ethereum
компиляция bitcoin ethereum bonus кошельки bitcoin monero алгоритм usdt tether новые bitcoin monero майнить se*****256k1 ethereum cryptocurrency mail bitcoin maining bitcoin bitcoin script ютуб bitcoin se*****256k1 bitcoin casascius bitcoin bitcoin frog bitcoin reindex cubits bitcoin ethereum info банк bitcoin bitcoin froggy контракты ethereum hash bitcoin эмиссия ethereum transaction bitcoin рост bitcoin китай bitcoin p2pool bitcoin monero node bitcoin hash bitcoin софт bitcoin miner statistics bitcoin machines bitcoin roboforex bitcoin ethereum упал tether криптовалюта bitcoin хардфорк tether wifi блокчейн bitcoin mac bitcoin bitcoin ютуб лото bitcoin
bitcoin instant
antminer bitcoin
monero xmr
bitcoin исходники ethereum упал bitcoin перевод блог bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin
tether download exchanges bitcoin bitcoin novosti exchange cryptocurrency Unauthorized miningUsers are hidden, but transactions aren’t. Everyone can see all the transactions that happen on the blockchain, but you can’t see the names of the users behind each transaction.bitcoin virus bitcoin 0 bitcoin multiplier best bitcoin apple bitcoin bitcoin review monero algorithm обзор bitcoin обменник bitcoin bitcoin 1000 bitcoin bitminer etherium bitcoin ethereum контракты rotator bitcoin код bitcoin bitcoin take monero прогноз ethereum nicehash monero обменять bitcoin bloomberg сложность bitcoin вывод ethereum
bitcoin магазины ethereum биткоин
bitcoin депозит bitcoin blocks ethereum course credit bitcoin bitcoin forex bitcoin 20 code bitcoin mining bitcoin ethereum habrahabr bitcoin capital bitrix bitcoin block bitcoin верификация tether fork bitcoin amazon bitcoin purse bitcoin hourly bitcoin mine ethereum polkadot bitcoin сша андроид bitcoin bitcoin приват24 tether майнить purse bitcoin bitcoin steam bitcoin server лото bitcoin bitcoin coingecko bitcoin make abc bitcoin ethereum pow ultimate bitcoin bitcoin life bitcoin кошелек alliance bitcoin check bitcoin монета ethereum bitcoin fork торги bitcoin bitcoin instaforex ютуб bitcoin
видеокарты ethereum bitcoin update автокран bitcoin bitcoin ann bitcoin раздача invest bitcoin форки ethereum all bitcoin ethereum обмен bitcoin value ethereum пулы loans bitcoin coingecko ethereum
gif bitcoin
daemon bitcoin вывод bitcoin bitcoin отслеживание bitcoin софт bitcoin bloomberg
bitcoin exe ethereum клиент компания bitcoin miner bitcoin bitcoin froggy бесплатный bitcoin forecast bitcoin iobit bitcoin tether купить battle bitcoin bitcoin review maps bitcoin electrum bitcoin gui monero bitcoin авито raspberry bitcoin
код bitcoin rx470 monero bitcoin баланс tether coin bitcoin анализ андроид bitcoin bitcoin genesis акции bitcoin monero amd график monero bitcoin перевод bitcoin desk xbt bitcoin генераторы bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin monero майнинг ethereum доходность
bitcoin gold bitcoin seed bitcoin кошелька bitcoin kaufen Bitcoins are completely virtual coins designed to be self-contained for their value, with no need for banks to move and store the money. Once bitcoins are owned by a person, they behave like physical gold coins. They possess value and trade just as if they were nuggets of gold. Bitcoins can be used to purchase goods and services online with businesses that accept them or can be tucked away in the hope that their value increases over time.cryptocurrency calculator прогнозы ethereum bitcoin gif блокчейна ethereum dao ethereum mine ethereum ethereum pow обновление ethereum bitcoin cli кран bitcoin bitcoin перспектива
курсы bitcoin split bitcoin purse bitcoin asrock bitcoin bitcoin ishlash адрес ethereum rx470 monero bitcoin bubble monero hardware APPLY( Alice: $50, Bob: $50 ,'send $20 from Alice to Bob') = Alice: $30, Bob: $70 bitcoin магазины аналоги bitcoin bitcoin bow и bitcoin bitcoin сервера
stock bitcoin ethereum contracts cryptocurrency price wikipedia bitcoin coingecko bitcoin bitcoin win bitcoin mac scrypt bitcoin история bitcoin bitcoin litecoin bitcoin skrill bitcoin carding mindgate bitcoin партнерка bitcoin bitcoin air king bitcoin bitcoin cny валюты bitcoin bitcoin проблемы криптовалюта monero
bitcoin airbit bitcoin blue bitcoin транзакции карты bitcoin tether обменник bitcoin clock bitcoin расшифровка polkadot su wei ethereum серфинг bitcoin продаю bitcoin monero купить bitcoin терминалы bitcoin market ecopayz bitcoin
bitcoin win транзакции bitcoin китай bitcoin fpga ethereum котировка bitcoin bitcoin добыча bitcoin poloniex bitcoin ukraine bitcoin goldman bitcoin кредиты
The bitcoin method of routinely using escrow has benefits over competitors like credit cards. The security of credit cards is not very good which results in higher costs overall and the possibility of payments being reversed for months afterwards. By contrast when bitcoins have been released to the seller from escrow, they cannot be reversed as the coins are truly in the seller's possession. The requirement to use real-life names for credit cards and PayPal also excludes unbanked people and those from countries with less developed financial infrastructure. There are also downsides like bitcoin is not yet as widely accepted as credit cards and is not a front for providing lines of credit.кошельки bitcoin bitcoin ethereum bitcoin buying зарабатываем bitcoin bitcoin conveyor bitcoin кран bitcoin visa ethereum charts monero stats ethereum email bitcoin monero краны bitcoin double maps bitcoin робот bitcoin bitcoin converter time bitcoin bitcoin clicker 15 bitcoin nicehash ethereum wallets cryptocurrency bitcoin исходники arbitrage bitcoin bitcoin 2010 it bitcoin cryptocurrency market
Decentralized Cryptocurrency Exchange Examplestether usd Using something called shared distributed ledger technology (SDLT), it allows a network of computers to update their files simultaneously using point-to-point encryption, and peer-to-peer replication. These can either be in the form of private networks or public networks. bitcoin 1070 coins bitcoin bitcoin nedir
cryptocurrency logo bear bitcoin инвестирование bitcoin bitcoin xl
bitcoin часы x2 bitcoin daemon bitcoin скрипт bitcoin ethereum zcash сложность ethereum работа bitcoin bitcoin 10 daily bitcoin bitcoin tm bitcoin кран bitcoin paper
бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin adder
bitcoin word boom bitcoin сайт ethereum bitcoin rub poloniex ethereum fpga bitcoin statistics bitcoin life bitcoin bonus bitcoin bitcoin вложения blue bitcoin продажа bitcoin bitcoin котировки сложность monero bitcoin работа cryptocurrency tech bitcoin safe bitcoin ne взлом bitcoin bitcoin shops
bitcoin скачать nanopool ethereum reverse tether clame bitcoin bitcoin joker bitcoin red doubler bitcoin
minergate bitcoin кошелька ethereum bitcoin client
bitcoin simple
wallets cryptocurrency demo bitcoin charts bitcoin pizza bitcoin p2pool monero система bitcoin bitcoin описание bitcoin indonesia trade cryptocurrency обновление ethereum
monero xmr trade cryptocurrency верификация tether история ethereum иконка bitcoin bitcoin курсы bitcoin convert bitcoin quotes курс monero обновление ethereum bitcoin minecraft
ethereum siacoin cryptocurrency это
my bitcoin bitcoin ваучер cryptocurrency calendar котировки bitcoin bitcoin mixer paypal bitcoin bitcoin goldmine rise cryptocurrency проекта ethereum mempool bitcoin trade cryptocurrency monero blockchain bitcoin обменять monero nvidia надежность bitcoin source bitcoin decred cryptocurrency free bitcoin bitcoin работать bitcoin гарант bitcoin блокчейн ethereum клиент сайт ethereum ethereum 4pda bitcoin bux
форекс bitcoin
currency bitcoin bitcoin обмена blocks bitcoin математика bitcoin polkadot store bitcoin yen bitcoin algorithm bitcoin хардфорк 1080 ethereum monero cryptonote динамика ethereum ethereum install bitcoin bloomberg tether limited nanopool ethereum bitcoin word bitcoin airbitclub bitcoin fpga
java bitcoin bitcoin facebook bitcoin png claim bitcoin bitcoin multiplier ethereum клиент bitcoin metal bitcoin gadget
bitcoin uk
monero js ethereum контракты ethereum pools bitcoin заработок top tether bitcoin игры currency bitcoin json bitcoin ethereum blockchain ava bitcoin ethereum видеокарты bitcoin doubler ethereum проблемы bitcoin phoenix ethereum эфир платформ ethereum market bitcoin difficulty ethereum javascript bitcoin bitcoin legal bitcoin бумажник maining bitcoin bitcoin scrypt блок bitcoin coingecko ethereum litecoin bitcoin bitcoin create новости ethereum bitcoin maps bitcoin проверка bitcoin обвал ethereum видеокарты
bitcoin office описание bitcoin monero 1060 bitcoin daemon
кредиты bitcoin bitcoin doubler bitcoin key bitcoin развод sgminer monero торрент bitcoin ethereum акции асик ethereum ethereum алгоритмы bitcoin рубль анализ bitcoin bitcoin apple
bitcoin future capitalization bitcoin
1024 bitcoin bitcoin news продам ethereum
But in order to distinguish undesirable conflict from spirited brainstorming, we must first define 'success' in an open allocation project context. Mere technical success—building a thing which achieves adoption—is certainly important at the outset of a project. But within a short time, the needs of users will evolve, as will the programmer’s understanding of the user and their goals. An inability to refactor or improve code over time will mean degraded performance and dissatisfaction, and the user base will eventually leave. Continuous maintenance and reassessment are the only way for initial success to continue into growth. Therefore, a regular and robust group of developers needs to be available and committed to the project, even if the founding members of the project leave.bitcoin neteller
